Return to RMBA Home Page
. Click on Read to read reviews written by other students for the 2010 Rocky Mountain Book Award.
These are unedited student reviews.
All-Season Edie
By Annabel Lyon
All Season Edie was an ok book. It was very odd because its not really a story telling book, more like the life of a pre-teen girl. I thought that the author didnt tie everything together well enough. I felt like it had no moral.
All Season Edie is a Good book for kids our age and goes on and on and is hard to follow
I don't want to be mean to the author or fans of this book, But I thought it was so confusing. Each chapter starts like a new book, and I didn't like how each chapter was 40 pages long. Some of the chapters had no meaning to it. It was weird because in one chapter Edie thought That she was a witch, and in another she thinks she saw a angel. I think that the Blackhawks will win the Stanley cup this year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :0
I loved All-Season Edie because each time you start a chapter, it’s like restarting the book all over again and it really tells you about 1 whole year in 1 great book so it’s 1 of the best books I ever read.
All season Edie is a wonderful it is jam packed with real life drama that is great for girls around 10-12 years old.I loved this book Annabel Lyon is a wonderful wrighter and i look forward to reading more of her books.
i L.O.V.E.D this book it was an awesome story
this is a funny and sad book! Edie has a sister,a mom,a dad,a grandpa,and a grandma. In this book Edie's grandpa dies (this is the sad part). But Edie has alot of other adventures during this book! I give this book a 10 out of 10! If you wan't to know what happens through out Edie's life then read this book!